The Dada movementMarcel Duchamp
|
|
|
|
Critics tend to declare that Marcel Duchamp's urinal, entitled Fountain, is the most important artwork of the 20th century. Yet its standing as a collectable object has always lagged behind its value as an idea. The work questioned notions of authenticity when Duchamp first purchased the mass-produced plumbing fixture and signed it "R. Mutt" in 1917. Now, over 40 years after the artist's death, the problem of legitimacy remains relevant as unauthorised urinals have been discovered circulating in Italy. The art world loves paradoxical conceptual gestures, but it seems that someone might be taking the piss.
"Fountain" was the first ready-made that Duchamp engineered for scandal. The artist was a member of the board of the Society of Independent Artists, whose exhibition had no jury and was set to be the largest in America. He knew that most people would perceive the work as a prank, particularly if submitted by an unknown Richard Mutt from Philadelphia. When the board duly voted against it, Duchamp and his chief patron, Walter Arensberg, resigned in protesta story that was swiftly leaked to the New York papers.
The ready-made had its public debut a few weeks later in an art magazine called the Blind Man. A photo of the urinal by Alfred Stieglitz was published alongside the founding manifesto of conceptual art, which included the words: "Whether Mr Mutt with his own hands made the fountain or not has no importance. He CHOSE it." The urinal then went the way of many of Duchamp's early ready-mades; it was smashed or trashed. So insignificant was the porcelain pissoir at the time that no one can remember exactly what happened to it.
"Fountain" was not a coveted art object until well after the second world war, when Duchamp became a cult figure among Pop artists. In response to the art world's desire to see his legendary lavatory, Duchamp authorised curators to purchase urinals in his name in 1950, 1953 and 1963. (The first is in the Philadelphia Museum of Art, the second is lost and the third sits in the Moderna Museet in Stockholm.) Then in 1964, in association with Arturo Schwarz, a Milan art dealer, historian and collector, the artist made the momentous decision to issue 12 replicas (an edition of eight with four proofs) of his most important ready-mades, including the urinal. Mr Schwarz, now 86, went on to write the artist's catalogue raisonnéa scholarly book meant to document the complete works of Duchamp.
As one who had painted moustaches on postcards of the Mona Lisa, Duchamp understood the power of reproductions to render a work iconic and consolidate an artist's international reputation. Indeed, nine of the 12 official Schwarz "Fountains" have been included in museum collections around the world. Of the three in private hands, one is in Bel Air, California, another is in Manhattan with the Mugrabi family, and the last, owned by Dimitris Daskalopoulos in Athens, will be exhibited at the Whitechapel Gallery in London this summer.
One of the many ironies of the Schwarz urinals is that they are carefully crafted earthenware sculptures modelled on the Stieglitz photo of the "original". Every edition has a story, but there is no beating the provenance of the 13th one. Dubbed "the prototype" and bearing Duchamp's signature, it slipped quietly onto the market in 1973 at the then fledgling gallery of Ronald Feldman in New York. Andy Warhol, who visited the gallery repeatedly, pressed Mr Feldman to trade the urinal for some of his own portraits. "Duchamp didn't sell well in those days," says Mr Feldman, "but Andy knew what multiples meant because he made them."
When Warhol died in 1987, his urinal was consigned to Sotheby's as part of his giant five-volume estate sale. "Fountain" was buried in a volume devoted to prints and given a lowly estimate of $2,000-2,500. It sold for $65,750 to Dakis Joannou, a Greek-Cypriot construction tycoon, and is now enshrined in the front hall of his main home in Athens. "I couldn't believe that we could actually own it," says Mr Joannou. "People didn't appreciate its historical importance, so we got a bargain." In the following decade, Duchamp's renown increased yet again, as did the marketing of his work. In 1999 Sotheby's put an official Schwarz urinal on the cover of its Contemporary Art evening sale catalogue; it commanded $1.8m.
Collectors of contemporary art are comfortable acquiring individual works in series, but they don't relish unlimited editions or dodgy authorship. Some may be dismayed to learn that there are at least three more "Duchamp urinals". Gio di Maggio, a collector whose Fondazione Mudima is in Milan, and Luisella Zignone, a Duchamp collector based in Biella, both have "Fountains" that Mr Schwarz says he gave as gifts. Sergio Casoli, a Milan dealer, is also thought to own one. (He declined to comment.)
Mr Schwarz claims that these works were made in 1964 under Duchamp's direction, but were not included in the original edition due to "imperfections". (It is unlikely that more than 17 urinals could have survived from this edition, but only Mr Schwarz knows for sure.) None of the newly discovered pieces have the "Marcel Duchamp" signature of official ready-mades. Nevertheless, the "Fountains" owned by Mr Di Maggio and Mrs Zignone have been shown in public institutions in Basel and Buenos Aires. In interview, Mr Schwarz reluctantly confirmed that he is trying to sell a fourth "Fountain" for an undisclosed sum, which one source says is $2.5m. (When pressed, Mr Schwarz says the asking price depends on whether the purchaser is a museum, a well-reputed collector or a speculator.)
The artist's estate is not pleased. Jacqueline Matisse Monnier, the head of the Association for the Protection and Conservation of works by Marcel Duchamp, says that "neither my mother nor I ever sanctioned the sale of unauthorised ready-mades." Mrs Monnier's mother, "Teeny", was married to Pierre Matisse, the dealer son of the Henri, before she married Duchamp, making her an heir to both the Henri Matisse and Duchamp estates. She sees Mr Schwarz's activities as curious given that "Arturo was a great friend of Marcel."
Some Duchamp connoisseurs are outraged. Francis M. Naumann, a scholar and dealer who has published widely on Duchamp, argues that these urinals cannot be considered Duchamps at all. "For Duchamp, the signature was everything," he argues. "It is the single most important element in the process of transforming an ordinary everyday object into a work of art."
Others appear more ambivalent. Daniella Luxembourg, co-owner of Luxembourg & Dayan, a New York gallery that recently held a Duchamp mini-retrospective, says the artist's market has "the atmosphere of relics in a religion," adding that "with globalisation, the differences between what was signed by Duchamp and what was in his vicinity will become smaller and smaller."
Duchamp's relationship to commerce was not naive. Although he preferred to give away his work rather than sell it, he made a living as an art dealer for many years. Duchamp was also an able chess player who could think a good few moves ahead. One wonders whether the Dada master, who challenged the notion of the authentic artwork, might not be amused by the way these questionable "Fountains" muddy the waters of his current market. "My production," he once said, "has no right to be speculated upon."
"Three Minute Wonder" by Mike Figgis. Must-see video on and about Duchamp's "Fountain".
It's definitely true that some things are funnier in English than they are in French and vice versa. I mean Duchamp was very well aware of this. Certain of his puns are totally untranslatable. Or they may be translatable but they still don't have the impact in translation because there'll be a nuance, a nuance or maybe just through French usage that will not translate or will be not come across.
A white gentlemen's urinal has been named the most influential modern art work of all time.
Marcel Duchamp's Fountain came top of a poll of 500 art experts in the run-up to this year's Turner Prize which takes place on Monday.
Picasso's Les Demoiselles d'Avignon (1907) was second, with Andy Warhol's Marilyn Diptych from 1962 coming third.
Duchamp shocked the art establishment when he took the urinal, signed it and put it on display in 1917.
"The choice of Duchamp's Fountain as the most influential work of modern art ahead of works by Picasso and Matisse comes as a bit of a shock," said art expert Simon Wilson.
Ahead of time
"But it reflects the dynamic nature of art today and the idea that the creative process that goes into a work of art is the most important thing - the work itself can be made of anything and can take any form."
Picasso's Spanish Civil War painting, Guernica, came fourth, while Matisse's The Red Studio was fifth.
Duchamp has influenced many contemporary artists, including Tracey Emin - her unmade bed was inspired by the French artist.
Copley's relationships with the surrealists were some of the most important and formative on his development as a person and an artist. He remained close friends with René Magritte, Man Ray, Max Ernst, and of course Marcel Duchamp. Marcel Duchamp died on October 2, 1968. He had been living primarily in New York since Copley met him in 1947. Copley was a frequent visitor to Duchamp's studio on Fourteenth Street once he returned to New York after his years in France. Upon Duchamp's death The William and Noma Copley Foundation (later the Cassandra Foundation) gave Marcel Duchamp's last work, "Etant Donnée" to the Philadelphia Museum of Art, where it is still on view. Copley had been one of the few people who knew that Duchamp was working on such a piece, and a major supporter of the work. William Copley's moving obituary of Duchamp that appeared in the New York Times on October 13, 1968 reflects the importance that Marcel had in his life:
Because I knew him, I find it inconceivable to speak of Marcel Duchamp as no longer living. For those who missed the point of his greatest statement, he has not been among them since he officially ceased painting years ago. Though he did not die that long ago he did define eternity, and he entered immortality at the time he left the easel and took art with him into creative life.
Had he been unwilling to share the experience, this would have been a fulsome obituary- and this is not an obituary.
If Marcel Duchamp ever dies, his Phoenix Rrose Selavy (a name having endless possibilities of punning transformation) mushroomed from the remains of a past he unshrouded when he inked in a moustache on the Mona Lisa, creating for himself and all of us a present in which the nouns "art" and "poetry" are forged into a single word.
The word was lying around for a long while, and it should not be suggested that he invented it. He was the first to discover how to articulate it, and the word is Yes.
"Art may be bad, good or indifferent, but whatever adjective is used, we must call it art, and bad art is still art in the same way that a bad emotion is still an emotion."
Or: "There is no solution because there is no problem. This was his way of saying "Yes" to the universe, the galaxies, the magno-microcosms, the explosions, the implosions, nature.
I like to think that hearing him say this with his own lips once saved my life. This may be mere sentimentality but I gladly risk saying it. Isn't the universe too grandiose, or don't the movements of the stars lack time to hear us therapeutically? Can vastness tolerate something as ridiculous as a solution?
Later it became "Yes" and "Chess" (fun and games with the laws of chance). Like Mallarmé, he recognized the implications of a single throw of the dice. Like Lautréamont he saw the beauty of mathematics. The Large Glass penetrates considerably beyond these implications to "canned chance" or "meta irony".
Freedom, wherever it may lead, was the revelation of his phoenix. Marcel Duchamp was long since with the Milky Ways.
by Jeffrey Shivar

Stock Certificate Sells for over One Million $An unusual stock certificate from 1924 from a company called Roulette de Monte Carlo, handsigned by Marcel Duchamp, was hammered at a Christie's auction for $1,082,500 including buyers premium. The certificate features a portrait of Duchamp by Man Ray, with Duchamp's face almost completely covered in shaving cream, and his hair pointed into horns like a devil.
There have been plenty of other old stock certificates, such as Houdini Picture Company stock certificates signed by Houdini, which sells for several thousand dollars, and even fairly modern worthless stock certificates, such as Enron, which sells for around $100. But the Duchamp certificate has achieved the highest price of any antique stock certificate by hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Marcel Duchamp's Dandyism : The Dandy, The Flaneur and The Beginnings of Mass Culture in New York during the 1910s
Marcel Duchamp World Community (MarcelDuchamp.Net)
The Marcel Duchamp World Community Web Site offers a neutral, unbiased, internet location for the meeting and exchange of ideas among the international community of people interested in Marcel Duchamp studies. The site welcomes news, events, publications, papers -- anything related to Marcel Duchamp and his larger circle of friends in Dada and Surrealism.
The Artworks of Marcel Duchamp
in 15 themes + a biography on WahooArt (an exceptional site).
![]() |
![]() |
Dada without Duchamp / Duchamp without Dada
An intelligent and well documented article by professor Marjorie Perloff.
Encounter with Marcel Duchamp
Includes a reproduction and an explanation of Étant donné, the important dates in Duchamp's life as well as other unpublished treasures.
Étant Donné Marcel Duchamp
Presentation and table of contents of the excellent periodical devoted to Duchamp, Étant Donné.
Marcel Duchamp and the Machine
by Alan Foljambe
An early example of Duchamp's attraction to machine form is Chocolate Grinder.
Marcel Duchamp in His Own Words
Duchamp comments in English in three consecutive clips on his evolution in painting and his implication in the iconoclastic ideas of Dada. Why did he take up chess? "Playing chess is like designing or constructing something." Of course his remarks stop before Étant Donné was revealed to the public in Philadelphia -- after his death.
Marcel Duchamp's Work
An excellent illustrated presentation of Duchamp's life and work from the Centre Pompidou in Paris.

Making Sense of Marcel Duchamp
Interactive animated chronicle which brings to life the ideas and influences at the source of Duchamp's art.
Marcel Duchamp News - The New York Times
News about Marcel Duchamp, including commentary and archival articles published in The New York Times.
Witch's Cradle (1943)
Rare silent film by Maya Deren with Marcel Duchamp.
Part 1
Part 2
Lydie Sarazin-Levassor, The Marcel Duchamp I married
Her memoirs, published for the first time in Britain, portray a desperate liaison. Excerpts in The Independent, 11/02/08.
Bits & Bites Duchamp
A website containing 9 superb photos of Marcel or his works.
Marcel Duchamp (1887-1968)
The Allen Ginsberg Project
On the occasion of the 43rd anniversary of Duchamp's death, an excellent collection of interview footage and Duchampiana.
Was Marcel Duchamp the Anti-Artist?
As an artist, Marcel Duchamp is hard to classify but he almost certainly wanted it that way. During his career, just when everyone thought they knew what he was, a Cubist, for example, or a Surrealist, he switched to another style or no-style, left town or the country or stopped being an artist and went off and played chess in tournaments.

This bottle of perfume « Belle Haleine - Eau de Voilette » and its cardbord container signed Marcel Duchamp were sold at auction for 7,9 million euros to the public's applause.